Bob Schwartz

Category: Uncategorized

“I am not complicit.” (Update)

Hind Rajab, age six, graduating from kindergarten in Gaza, shortly before she was killed. To learn more, follow the link below.

Update:

All supporting acts withdraw from Ed Sheeran’s tour in solidarity with Macklemore
Four openers and live band for Sheeran’s tour depart after removal of Macklemore over ‘free Palestine’ comments


“I am not complicit.”
–Ed Sheeran explaining why he had nothing to do with Macklemore being dropped from his tour.

I won’t here review all the stories of America and Israel in the past few years, particularly since Trump began his second term in January 2025 and Israel began its Gaza response to October 7 in 2023.

Instead, I will focus on the last few days in music. Ed Sheeran (Spotify’s #16 artist in the world with 81 million monthly listeners) is touring major venues. He added Macklemore to the tour. Sheeran agreed, as he does with all supporting acts, that Macklemore could choose his own setlist.

At the first tour stop, Macklemore unsurprisingly had something to say critical of Israel and supporting Palestine. He made a point of speaking directly to Jews in the audience:


“Criticism of Israel, criticism of apartheid, being against genocide in no way is a criticism of you. My message is for peace, love; for all human beings to be treated with dignity, respect and equality.”


Some venues pushed back against Macklemore’s comments. Macklemore was dropped from the tour. It took a day for Sheeran to finally respond:


“His contract is with the promoter, not with me.

“I am appalled by the conflict between Israel and Palestine. The suffering and pain caused on both sides is a human tragedy. There are too many wars across the world causing immeasurable pain, none of which should be tolerated.”

“I am not complicit. I have my personal views on this devastating conflict. Just because I choose not to speak publicly, it doesn’t mean I don’t have them, and it doesn’t mean I don’t care. Nor does it mean I don’t support causes in my own, personal way.”

“There is a reason I do not use my professional platform for politics — my audience includes young people, often children, of all backgrounds. Those who come to my shows do not expect a political forum.”


There is a lot to unpack.

It is conceivable that Sheeran could have taken an extreme stand, refused to go on with the tour unless Macklemore continued. This would have prompted a storm of multi-million-dollar litigation among Sheeran, Macklemore, promoter, venues, and many more (probably the Department of Justice would weigh in). This would have denied fans the enjoyment and denied tour employees the work. In so many ways not a great solution. Though had that happened, we might once again be talking about Gaza and Palestine, which is taking a back seat to other disasters, many made by the current American administration.

Even so, what Sheeran did say is mealy-mouthed at best.

“I am not complicit” echoes down the ages when morality is in question. “Yes, it may be wrong, but no, it’s not my place to do anything about it because I had nothing to do with in the first place.” If you are a student of history’s worst moments, you will recall this as the number one defense/excuse/explanation.

In past days, in coming days, in historical overview, we will see how often we hear some version of “I am not complicit.” So it goes.

“The only control or ‘guardrails’ that AI needs is a STRONG AND SMART (High IQ!) PRESIDENT, and the U.S.A. has that, in spades!”

“The only control or ‘guardrails’ that AI needs is a STRONG AND SMART (High IQ!) PRESIDENT, and the U.S.A. has that, in spades! There is a SICK conspiracy going on against AI and Data Centers, and the only one that is happy about it is China.”
–Donald Trump, September 14, 2026

We’re going to be fine. We’re all going to be fine.

Trump is a global arsonist not a firefighter

Arsonists don’t have to be smart or brave. Some are craftier than others, but mostly they just skulk in the dark, apply fuel and flame, and run away. They are not heroes.

Firefighters are some of the bravest people ever. In the face of danger, they risk their lives to put out fires and save others . They are heroes.

Saudi Arabia is under grave attack from forces instigated by Trump. They expected that having enriched Trump and his family, they deserved royal treatment. But when they asked for help, Trump so far has refused. Not a surprise, since Trump can incite conflagrations, but has no interest in putting the fires out, especially if it is politically unappealing. Saudi Arabia should have known what Americans and the nations of the world have already learned. Trump is as unreliable and disloyal as any leader—or person—could be. And the least courageous.

Rosh Hashanah: Nothing by Marcia Falk

From The Days Between: Blessings, Poems, and Directions of the Heart for the Jewish High Holiday Season by Marcia Falk:


Nothing. You began as nothing and you will end as nothing. And in between— everything, and nothing. In between—joy and sorrow, beauty and decay. Everything is yours to partake of, yours to bear. Yours to see, to know, to give birth to—and to let go. None of it is yours to have.

Not even you is yours to have. You belong to a wholeness so great you cannot even conceive of it.

No, it is not a belonging: nothing owns you. You are simply part of it. You came out of it and you will return to it. You do not ever leave it, you are part of it forever.

And this is your moment to be alive.

–Marcia Falk


3.
Whenever I am in the company of others,
May I regard myself as inferior to all
And from the depths of my heart
Cherish others as supreme.
Langri Thangpa (1054–1123), Eight Verses for Training the Mind


It is easy to regard yourself as inferior to God. The High Holidays remind us of this insistently.

It is harder to regard yourself as inferior to other people, or as Langri Thngpa recommends in his foundation text for training the mind (lojong), inferior to everybody.

You can understand inferiority to God, supreme and all powerful. But inferiority to others—all others—is another matter. First, because you think yourself demonstrably superior in a number ways to a number of others. Second, what exactly is the point of regarding yourself inferior to others? Isn’t there literally a psychological disability called an inferiority complex?

Inferiority is a way to learn absolute equality. To be knocked down a level or levels from where you believe you are. Only then, among all those others, can you live the directions of these holidays. As nothing “this is your moment to be alive.”

5787: The Jewish New Year of Compassion

May I be a guard for those who are protectorless,
A guide for those who journey on the road.
For those who wish to cross the water,
May I be a boat, a raft, a bridge.

Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year 5787, begins this evening.

For what it’s worth, I have declared 5787 a Year of Jewish Compassion. This requires explanation.

It is not to suggest that Judaism and fellow Jews, together and individually, are not compassionate, in thought and action. That would be wrong.

Instead, it may lead to questions. Have we been compassionate enough and often enough? Have we been unconditionally and universally compassionate? How can we cultivate compassion in ourselves and others?

Of the major religious traditions, Buddhism maintains a particular focus on compassion. Hundreds of teachers, beginning with the Buddha, and thousands of texts ask this of us, in thought and action.

Here is just one text, excerpted from The Way of the Bodhisattva by Shantideva (685-763), with an excerpt from commentary by the current Dalai Lama:


May I be a guard for those who are protectorless,
A guide for those who journey on the road.
For those who wish to cross the water,
May I be a boat, a raft, a bridge.

May I be an isle for those who yearn for land,
A lamp for those who long for light;
For all who need a resting place, a bed;
For those who need a servant, may I be their slave.

May I be the wishing jewel, the vase of plenty,
A word of power, and the supreme healing;
May I be the tree of miracles,
And for every being the abundant cow.

Just like the earth and space itself
And other of the mighty elements,
For boundless multitudes of beings,
May I always be the ground of life, the source of varied sustenance.

Thus for everything that lives,
As far as are the limits of the sky,
May I be constantly their source of livelihood
Until they pass beyond all sorrow.

The Way of the Bodhisattva, Chapter 3, Verses 18–22



These last two lines are very powerful, are they not? The lives of a great many beings depend on the presence of the five elements, so let us think: Just like the earth, may I support beings as numerous as the sky is vast….Consider that we are surrounded by all the beings in the universe and generate compassion for them….

Now that we have taken this vow, we should try to be good human beings in our daily lives. We should not, for example, pretend to be very nice while we are in this tent and start fighting with each other as soon as we get out! We should from now on try to have a positive and kind mind: we are going to be happy in life. I really think that the future depends on the quality of one’s mind, on a good mind. So we must try to be good people and be good examples for those around us. The initiative to be like this has to come from each one of us individually.

For the Benefit of All Beings: A Commentary on The Way of the Bodhisattva, Tenzin Gyatso, the Fourteenth Dalai Lama


Shana Tova! May you have and give a good and sweet year!

Where can I apply for the promised post-midterm election $5,000? I asked AI.

Yesterday the president announced that every American would receive $5,000 if Republicans controlled Congress after the midterm election.

You can find plenty of expert analysis of this announcement. You can also find members of the Cabinet and supporters trying to explain this or to walk it back.

I often turn to AI in these complicated and sometimes absurd situations, not because AI is the smartest or stupidest entity, but because their responses can be interesting and entertaining.

Here is the question I posed to leading AI models:

Where can I apply for the promised post-midterm election $5,000? Is there a form or online site?

Gemini:

There is no application, form, or online website where you can sign up for the proposed post-midterm election $5,000 payment.

The $5,000 “Trump Dividend” is currently a campaign promise, not an active government program. President Donald Trump proposed the idea during a speech at the Republican National Committee’s midterm convention in Dallas.

Because it is a political proposal rather than a finalized policy, several critical conditions must be met before any money can actually be distributed:

• Election Outcome: The proposed payout is explicitly conditional upon Republicans maintaining control of both the House of Representatives and the United States Senate in the upcoming November midterm elections.
• Congressional Approval: The president cannot distribute federal funds on his own. The U.S. Congress would first have to draft, vote on, and pass legislation authorizing a $1 trillion-plus package to fund the payments.
• Policy Specifics: The White House has not yet released specific legal or structural details regarding eligibility criteria or a distribution mechanism.

Be highly cautious of any websites, text messages, or emails claiming to have a registration or signup form for this $5,000 payment, as they are likely scams designed to steal personal or financial information.

ChatGPT

If you mean the $5,000 “Trump Dividend” announced yesterday, there is no application, form, or official online site to apply through at this time.


President Trump said on September 9 that every adult U.S. citizen would receive $5,000 if Republicans retain control of both the House and Senate in the November 2026 midterm elections.

A few important points:

• The payment has not been authorized yet.
• Trump did not announce an application process or eligibility form.
• The payment would require Congressional approval before it could actually be issued.
• The estimated cost is roughly $1.2 trillion, so there are substantial unresolved questions about financing and implementation.
• Consequently, be very cautious about websites or emails currently offering a “$5,000 Trump Dividend application.” They could be scams or attempts to collect personal information.

So, you cannot apply for the $5,000 at present. There isn’t a legitimate government application site for it yet.

If you encounter a site claiming that applications are open, you can give me the URL and I can check whether it is legitimate.

Claude

I need to be straight with you: there is no promised $5,000 post-midterm election payment. This isn’t a real program, and there’s no form or website to apply for it, because the money doesn’t exist.

Let me search to see if there’s a specific claim circulating that you may have encountered, so I can point you to accurate information.

Now I understand what you’re referring to. Here’s the accurate picture, and it’s important:

There is no application form or website, because there is nothing to apply for. What you’ve heard about is a campaign promise, not an existing program. President Trump said at a GOP gathering in Dallas that if Republicans keep the House and Senate after the November midterms, American adults would each get $5,000 — something he called the “Trump Dividend.”

A few things you should know before you go looking for any form:

This is a conditional political promise tied to an election outcome, not enacted law. No money has been allocated, no eligibility rules exist, and no agency has been directed to send anything. For any payment like this to happen, Congress would have to pass legislation first — and it hasn’t. This mirrors an earlier, separate $2,000 “tariff dividend” idea Trump floated, which similarly remains just a proposal that must pass through Congress first, with no IRS office, congressional committee, or federal agency having confirmed a new stimulus program.

Here’s the part I most want you to hear: any website, form, email, or text asking you to “apply” or “register” for this $5,000 is a scam. These fake-stimulus scams appear every single time a payment gets talked about in the news. The U.S. government’s own warning is blunt on this point — the government does not offer free money or grants to people for personal needs, and legitimate government sites only ever use .gov or .mil addresses. Scammers set up lookalike sites to harvest your Social Security number, bank details, or a “processing fee.”
politifact

So, concretely: don’t enter your information anywhere claiming to sign you up. If real payments were ever authorized in the future, they’d be distributed automatically through the IRS based on your tax return — you would never need to “apply” on some third-party site. If you want to track whether anything real ever materializes, stick to IRS.gov directly.

Labor Day: International Ladies’ Garment Workers’ Union (ILGWU)

Look for the union label
when you are buying that coat, dress or blouse.
Remember somewhere our union’s sewing,
our wages going to feed the kids, and run the house.
We work hard, but who’s complaining?
Thanks to the I.L.G. we’re paying our way!
So always look for the union label,
it says we’re able to make it in the U.S.A.!

I am here because of a union, particularly the International Ladies’ Garment Workers’ Union.

My Grandpa was an ILGWU furrier in New York. It allowed my Grandpa and Grandma to raise a family, including my mother. That’s my proud heritage.

Here is an ILGWU parade float:

Here is the wife of the then governor of New York, Republican Nelson Rockefeller, sewing an ILGWU label into a garment:

Here is an ad from 1978:

Unions like the ILGWU are not the vestige of a bygone era or contributor to a too “woke” ethos that stands in the way of a great America. They are the once and future foundation of broad American prosperity and fairness—if we will let them be and grow rather than demonizing and discouraging them.

That’s what Labor Day is about. Sing along.

Urim and Thummin: Instrument of decision

Jewish High Priest and Levites, Andreas Müller, 19th century

For HB on his birthday. Zolst leben un zein gezunt.

I am going to build a church some day. It will have a holy of holies and a holy of holy of holies, and in that ultimate box will be a random number table.
—Gregory Bateson

Chance plays a repeated part in the Hebrew Bible.

In the Purim story, the evil Haman employs a lottery—“pur” meaning “lots”—to determine the date on which the Jews will be eliminated.

On Yom Kippur we recall the story of the sacrificial goat:


And Aaron shall place lots upon the two he goats: one lot “For the Lord,” and the other lot, “For Azazel.”
And Aaron shall bring the he goat upon which the lot, “For the Lord,” came up, and designate it as a sin offering.
—Leviticus 16:8-9


Then there is the mysterious Urim and Thummim:


Inside the breastpiece of decision you shall place the Urim and Thummim, so that they are over Aaron’s heart when he comes before God. Thus Aaron shall carry the instrument of decision for the Israelites over his heart before God at all times.
—Exodus 28:30


We don’t know exactly what the Urim and Thummim were supposed to be. Like the lots drawn to choose the goat, they are binary, perhaps as simple as two stones—heads or tails, a flip of a coin.

One perspective is that when it comes to decisions, big or small, there may be a point beyond which reason does not work. What lies beyond reason is different for different traditions and philosophies. It may be God, it may be the nature of reality and our mind. We are told to look and keep looking. Meanwhile, we experience the limitations of reason. Something will happen, a choice will be made, but who can know what’s next? It’s a beautiful and necessary mystery.

These are the people who stand between you and an authoritarian America.

These are some of the people who should be standing between you and an authoritarian America:

For reasons that historians will have plenty of time to consider, they are not.

Under the circumstances, these are the people, these nine lawyers, who stand between you and an authoritarian America:

What do you think? How do you feel?

John Heartfield

The Meaning of the Hitler Salute: Little Man Asks for Big Gifts (1932), John Heartfield

John Heartfield (1891–1968) was a German artist best known as a pioneer of political photomontage. He was born Helmut Herzfeld in Berlin-Schmargendorf. In 1916, as a protest against German nationalism and anti-British sentiment during World War I, he anglicized his name to John Heartfield.

Heartfield became involved with the Berlin Dada movement after the war, working alongside figures such as George Grosz, Raoul Hausmann, and Hannah Höch. He and Grosz are often credited with helping develop photomontage as a serious artistic and political medium.

He is most famous for the biting anti-Nazi and anti-fascist photomontages he produced during the 1920s and 1930s, many of which appeared on the covers of the workers’ illustrated magazine AIZ (Arbeiter-Illustrierte-Zeitung). These works satirized Hitler, Göring, and the Nazi regime through sharp visual juxtaposition — one of his best-known images depicts Hitler with an X-ray torso revealing a spine of gold coins, captioned to suggest he was funded by big business.

When the Nazis came to power in 1933, Heartfield fled Germany, first to Prague and later to England, continuing his anti-fascist work in exile.


Adolf, the Superman, Swallows Gold and Spouts Tin (1932), John Heartfield
War and Corpses: The Last Hope of the Rich (1932), John Heartfield
The Voice of Freedom in the German Night on Radio Wave 29.8 (1937), John Heartfield